Skip to content
Living

16 School Supplies That Cost Pennies Then but Are Worth Hundreds Now

60s school supplies 1

Who would have thought that the simple classroom supplies from the 1960s and 1970s would become trendy? Once classroom supplies that sat in every student’s desk for a couple of pennies are now serious money for nostalgic collectors. Here are some classroom supplies that have become highly collectible.

1. Vintage Lunch Boxes (Then: $2.99, Now: $400+)

A 1964 The Munsters lunch box showcasing its iconic design and collectible value.
Image Credit: OpenAI

TV shows and movie lunchboxes have become very collectible, especially metal ones. The 1954 Superman lunchbox recently sold for over a thousand dollars. Common lunchboxes can sell for hundreds, especially if the thermos is in good condition.

Save for later

Want to come back to this story? Save it with your email so it is easy to find again.

2. Slide Rules (Then: $1.95, Now: $200+)

A vintage slide rule, a classic school supply every 70s kid used, now obsolete.
Image Credit: Public Domain

Before calculators, you needed an advanced math tool in your class. Certain brands like Keuffel & Esser are very expensive. The leather cases can sell for 50 dollars.

3. Fountain Pens (Then: 50¢, Now: $300+)

A collection of vintage fountain pens, showcasing items that may be worth thousands today.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Standard school pens, especially Esterbrook models have become very collectible. Ink bottles and nibs can become collectibles and some rare models sell for over 500 dollars if they are in the original box.

4. Metal Pencil Boxes (Then: 25¢, Now: $150+)

A vintage metal pencil box, a staple school supply defined in the '50s.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Decorative metal school pencil boxes especially with themes such as cartoons or space are in huge demand. Original ones designed by Dick and Jane sell for hundreds.

5. School Pennants (Then: 75¢, Now: $175+)

Colorful roadside attraction pennants showcasing nostalgic vacation spots.
Image Credit: OpenAI

School pennants made out of felt, especially from schools that have closed down, are in big demand. The colorful and unique designs bring great decoration. College pennants from the 1960’s are very valuable.

6. Book Covers (Then: 10¢, Now: $50+)

Vinyl book covers from the 70s, a nostalgic school supply now obsolete.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Book covers made out of paper with prints of designs or ads are very collectible. Covers that are in original and untouched condition are very valuable, and movie and TV themed covers are the most valuable.

7. Protractors and Compass Sets (Then: $1.25, Now: $125+)

Vintage protractors and compasses that evoke nostalgia and memories of school days.
Image Credit: OpenAI

German-made geometry sets are some of the most collectible educational tools. The exact measuring tools are often kept in leather or wooden cases and sets with all their pieces sell for hundreds.

8. School Library Cards (Then: Free, Now: $25+)

Image of a vintage library card catalog, showcasing how kids once searched for books.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Original library card pockets and their cards have also become collectible. Cards with notable titles or several signatures are the most valuable. Complete sets from inactive schools can go for quite a bit.

9. Vintage Globes (Then: $4.99, Now: $200+)

A colorful globe bank showcasing how school supplies can hold memories.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Teacher’s globes from the 1960s are especially desirable. Those with lights or special stands are more valuable. The political changes that have occurred since then have increased these collectibles’ desirability.

10. School Desk Bells (Then: $1.50, Now: $75+)

60s school supplies
Image Credit: OpenAI

Small brass bells from teachers’ desks have become decorative collectibles. They’re popular as display pieces because of the sharp tone and solid construction. Desirability is increased by original wooden handles and manufacturer’s marks.

11. Pencil Sharpeners (Then: 89¢, Now: $150+)

Image of a classic manual pencil sharpener, a staple school supply from the '50s.
Image Credit: OpenAI

Mounted pencil sharpeners, especially with Boston designs, can be quite expensive. The vacuum mounted version is the most desirable. Original paint with a working mechanism can double the value.

12. Report Card Holders (Then: 15¢, Now: $45+)

60s school supplies 1
Image Credit: OpenAI

Report card holders in leather or vinyl from schools with logos or mascots have also become collectibles. The most valuable ones are unused and in their original condition. The rare designs that come from top-tier schools can sell for over $100.

13. School Maps (Then: $5.99, Now: $300+)

60s school supplies 2
Image Credit: OpenAI

Classroom pull-down maps showing former historical borders are also highly collectible. Nystrom maps from the 1960s are the most coveted. Complete sets with their mounts can sell for thousands.

14. Flash Cards (Then: 29¢, Now: $40+)

60s school supplies 3
Image Credit: OpenAI

Educational flash card sets, particularly with original instruction sheets and boxes, are more valuable. Complete sets, especially of science and math, have become highly collectible. Unique illustrations are especially valuable.

15. School Badges (Then: 25¢, Now: $85+)

60s school supplies 4
Image Credit: OpenAI

School safety patrol & hall monitor badges, like other metal school badges, have become popular collectibles. Badges with enameled designs and original backing cards increase value even more. Some rare official badges can even go for more than 200 dollars.

16. Wooden Rulers (Then: 10¢, Now: $30+)

60s school supplies 5
Image Credit: OpenAI

Wooden rulers, especially with advertising or school logos, have also become surprising collectibles. Rulers with unusual measuring systems or with conversion tables are even more valuable. value is also affected by original finish and clear markings.