The Worst Episodes of Dickinson: When Emily’s Brilliance Fell Flat

As a die-hard fan of “Dickinson,” I have to admit that even the best TV shows have a few episodes that don’t quite hit the mark. While the show’s unique blend of historical drama and modern sensibility usually keeps me hooked, there are a handful of episodes that left me feeling less than inspired. So, in the spirit of friendly critique, I’ve compiled a list of the worst episodes of “Dickinson” that you might want to skip over in your next binge-watch. From cringeworthy poetry slams to lackluster love triangles, these episodes just didn’t quite live up to the show’s usual standards. But fear not, fellow fans, there are still plenty of poetic gems to be found in the rest of the series.
“Hope” is the thing with feathers

“Hope” is the thing with feathers

Release Date: 2021-11-04

“Dickinson” Season 3 – Episode 1 is a somber start to the season. The episode revolves around the death of Austin and Sue’s young son, Gib. While the family mourns their loss, Emily struggles to keep everyone together and maintain peace. The episode feels heavy and slow, lacking the usual wit and charm that the show is known for. Even Emily’s poetic musings fall flat in this episode, with lines like, “We’re all just candles in the wind, aren’t we?” feeling forced and uninspired. While the show has tackled heavy topics before, this episode feels like a misstep. Overall, it’s a forgettable and lackluster start to an otherwise fantastic series.

It feels a shame to be Alive -

It feels a shame to be Alive –

Release Date: 2021-11-04

“Dickinson Season 3 – Episode 2” is a snooze fest that fails to deliver any meaningful plot development. The episode centers around Frazar Stearns leaving for the battlefield, but even that fails to generate any excitement. As the Dickinson family welcomes a new life, viewers are left wondering why they should care about any of the characters. The dialogue is lackluster, with forgettable lines like “I don’t know how to be a mother” and “I’m scared.” The episode drags on for what feels like an eternity, with no real payoff at the end. Overall, “Dickinson Season 3 – Episode 2” is a forgettable episode that deserves its spot on the list of the worst episodes of the series.

The Soul has Bandaged moments

The Soul has Bandaged moments

Release Date: 2021-11-04

“Dickinson Season 3 – Episode 3” is a snoozefest that will have you reaching for the remote to change the channel. The episode revolves around Emily and Lavinia hosting a sewing circle to support the troops, with the help of Amherst’s finest seamstress, Betty. Sounds exciting, right? Wrong. The episode is a slow burn that fails to ignite any interest or excitement. Even the normally quirky and witty dialogue falls flat in this episode. The only memorable moment is when Emily declares, “I don’t know how to sew, but I do know how to write,” which is quickly overshadowed by the dullness that ensues. Save yourself the time and skip this episode.

This is my letter to the World

This is my letter to the World

Release Date: 2021-11-11

“Dickinson” Season 3, Episode 4, is a dull and forgettable episode that fails to capture the essence of the series. Emily tries to connect with the pain of war by writing letters to a Union Army colonel and visiting a war hospital. However, her attempts fall flat, and the episode lacks any emotional impact or engaging plotlines. Meanwhile, Henry takes a new job teaching soldiers, but his storyline feels underdeveloped and uninteresting. Overall, the episode is a slow and uneventful hour of television that fails to capture the charm and wit of the series. As Emily herself once said, “Forever is composed of nows,” but this episode is one now that viewers won’t want to remember.

Sang from the Heart, Sire

Sang from the Heart, Sire

Release Date: 2021-11-18

“Dickinson” Season 3 Episode 5 is a cringe-worthy attempt at a family singalong that devolves into yet another family feud. Emily tries to celebrate her father’s birthday in a traditional way, but her mother and siblings have other ideas. The result is a cacophony of bad singing, insults, and passive-aggressive comments that make you wish you were anywhere else but watching this episode. The most memorable moment is when Emily’s brother Austin declares, “I’m not singing with you, Emily, you always sing too loud,” which perfectly encapsulates the dysfunction of the Dickinson family. This episode is a prime example of the show’s tendency to prioritize quirky humor over character development, and it deserves a spot on the list of the worst episodes of “Dickinson.”

A little Madness in the Spring

A little Madness in the Spring

Release Date: 2021-11-24

“Dickinson Season 3 – Episode 6” takes a strange turn as the Dickinson family decides to visit an asylum for a fun family outing. As if that wasn’t odd enough, Henry spends his time helping soldiers with uniform inspections. The episode is a jarring departure from the show’s usual quirky charm, and the forced attempts at humor fall flat. The only saving grace is Emily’s brief moment of introspection as she reflects on her mental health and her own potential institutionalization. However, even that is overshadowed by the overall cringe factor of the episode. As Emily herself once said, “The brain is wider than the sky,” but unfortunately, this episode falls far short of that mark.

The Future never spoke

The Future never spoke

Release Date: 2021-12-02

Dickinson Season 3 – Episode 7 is easily one of the worst episodes of the series. The episode follows Emily as she deals with a fallout with Sue and wishes to escape the troubles of her time. Meanwhile, Austin grapples with his responsibility as a man during wartime. The episode fails to offer any significant character development or plot advancement, leaving viewers feeling unfulfilled and bored. Even the usually witty and charming dialogue falls flat, with no iconic quotes or memorable moments to speak of. Overall, this episode is a forgettable and lackluster addition to an otherwise enjoyable series.

My Life had stood – a Loaded Gun -

My Life had stood – a Loaded Gun –

Release Date: 2021-12-09

As a fan of the show, it pains me to say that Dickinson Season 3, Episode 8 is one of the worst episodes of the series. The episode centers around a soldier’s memorial, which becomes a catalyst for Emily’s spiraling mental health. Her efforts to keep her family’s hope alive reach a breaking point, and she descends into a personal inferno. While the show is known for its unique blend of humor and drama, this episode leans heavily towards the latter, with few moments of levity. The episode lacks the quirky charm that made the earlier seasons so engaging, and instead feels like a slog through Emily’s darkest moments. While the show is often praised for its feminist themes, this episode falls short in its portrayal of mental illness, with Emily’s struggles feeling more like a plot device than a nuanced exploration of her character. As Emily herself says in the episode, “I am a mess.” Unfortunately, this episode is too.

Grief is a Mouse

Grief is a Mouse

Release Date: 2021-12-16

As a devoted viewer of Dickinson, it pains me to include an episode from the beloved show on a list of worst episodes, but alas, Episode 9 of Season 3 left much to be desired. The episode revolves around Emily’s attempts to prevent her family from repeating past mistakes, which sounds promising, but unfortunately falls flat. The plot feels lackluster and fails to capture the same energy and excitement as previous episodes. Even the typically hilarious banter between the Amherst gang feels forced and uninspired. One memorable moment includes Emily telling her sister, “I’m not going to let you make the same mistakes I did,” but even this line fails to pack a punch. Overall, Episode 9 fails to live up to the high standards set by previous episodes, making it a disappointing addition to the series.

The Daisy follows soft the Sun

The Daisy follows soft the Sun

Release Date: 2021-01-15

“Dickinson” season 2, episode 4, titled “The Daisy follows soft the Sun,” is undoubtedly one of the worst episodes of the series. The episode follows Emily Dickinson, who is suffering from writer’s block after not hearing from her love interest, Sam. In an attempt to find inspiration, Emily goes on a walk in the countryside, where she encounters a group of men who are looking to kill a snake. The episode’s plotline is boring and uneventful, and the characters’ conversations lack depth and substance. One of the few memorable moments is when Emily speaks to the snake, personifying it as a symbol of her own suppressed desires. Overall, “The Daisy follows soft the Sun” fails to captivate its audience, and its lack of substance and poor execution make it one of the worst episodes of “Dickinson.”

Forbidden Fruit a flavor has

Forbidden Fruit a flavor has

Release Date: 2021-01-22

Dickinson Season 2 – Episode 5 seems to be one of the worst episodes of the series. The episode revolves around Emily Dickinson’s desire to be published by Sam and her attempts to fit in at Sue’s salon. However, the plot feels forced and predictable, lacking the charm and wit that made the show so engaging in the first season. There are some memorable moments, like when Emily reads her poem at the salon, but they are few and far between. Even the dialogue, which is usually a highlight of the show, feels stilted and uninspired. Overall, Dickinson Season 2 – Episode 5 is a disappointing entry in an otherwise enjoyable series. As Emily herself might say, “That it will never come again is what makes life so sweet.” But unfortunately, this episode is one that we won’t be eager to revisit.

This was a Poet -

This was a Poet –

Release Date: 2021-12-23

“Dickinson” Season 3 Episode 10 is a disappointing finale that leaves viewers wanting more. The episode centers around Emily asking Betty to help her design a new dress, which is a lackluster plotline that fails to capture the essence of the show. The Dickinson family is surprised by an unexpected guest, but even this plot twist falls flat. The episode is slow-paced, uneventful, and lacks the wit and charm that made the previous seasons so enjoyable. As Emily says in the episode, “I feel like I’m in a dream, but I don’t know whose dream it is.” Unfortunately, this sentiment applies to the entire episode, which feels like a forgettable dream that fails to live up to the show’s potential. Overall, this lackluster finale earns a spot on the list of the worst episodes of “Dickinson.”

The only Ghost I ever saw

The only Ghost I ever saw

Release Date: 2021-01-08

“Dickinson” Season 2 Episode 3 is a lackluster addition to the series, failing to deliver on its potential. The episode centers around Emily’s indecision about whether to allow Sam to publish her work. In an attempt to gain clarity, she hosts a séance, but the results are underwhelming and do little to advance the plot. The dialogue is uninspired, and the characters seem to be going through the motions without any real purpose. The episode’s one saving grace is the performance of Hailee Steinfeld as Emily, but even her talent cannot salvage this forgettable installment. As Emily herself might say, “I felt a Funeral, in my Brain,” watching this episode.

You cannot put a Fire out

You cannot put a Fire out

Release Date: 2021-02-26

“Dickinson” season 2, episode 10, is a snooze-fest, to say the least. The whole town is celebrating the christening of Jane’s baby, but Emily spends the entire episode whining about getting her poems back from Sam. The only memorable moment is when Emily’s sister Lavinia finally stands up to her and calls her out on her selfishness. Even Emily’s usual witty one-liners fall flat in this episode. As she says, “I’m not a poet, I’m a thief” – stealing our precious time with this lackluster plot. This episode certainly deserves a spot on the list of worst episodes of “Dickinson.”

I am afraid to own a Body

I am afraid to own a Body

Release Date: 2019-11-01

In Dickinson Season 1 Episode 5, Emily attends a meeting of the local Shakespeare Club and is forced to confront tough issues, including racism and sexism. While the show is known for its unique blend of modern language and historical settings, this episode falls short with its heavy-handed approach to these topics. The dialogue feels forced and contrived, lacking the wit and charm that makes the show so enjoyable. Even Emily’s typically sharp tongue fails to save this episode from being one of the worst of the season. As she declares, “I’m sorry, but that was a hot mess,” viewers can’t help but agree.

‘Faith’ is a fine invention

‘Faith’ is a fine invention

Release Date: 2019-11-01

“Dickinson” season 1 episode 9 was a disappointing and lackluster entry in the series. The episode revolves around Emily’s encounter with the Shadow of Death during a solar eclipse. Despite the potential for a haunting and thrilling storyline, the episode fails to deliver any real scares or emotional impact. Instead, it feels disjointed and poorly executed, with awkward dialogue and unconvincing acting. The only redeeming quality is the brief appearance of Wiz Khalifa as Death, but even his performance can’t save this episode from being one of the worst of the season. As Emily herself says, “I don’t understand what’s happening, but it’s not good.” And unfortunately, that sentiment applies to this episode as a whole.

We lose - because we win

We lose – because we win

Release Date: 2019-11-01

In “Dickinson” season 1, episode 7, entitled “We Lose – Because We Win,” Emily Dickinson’s rebellious spirit reaches new heights as she attempts to publish another poem on her father’s election day. Unfortunately, this episode falls flat with its lack of character development and a meandering plot. While the show’s modern take on the 19th century poet’s life is usually refreshing, this episode feels like a filler with no real substance. Even iconic quotes like “Success is counted sweetest by those who ne’er succeed” cannot save this lackluster episode from being one of the worst of the series.

I felt a Funeral, in my Brain

I felt a Funeral, in my Brain

Release Date: 2019-11-01

“Dickinson” Season 1 Episode 10 is a lackluster season finale that fails to deliver the emotional punch viewers were hoping for. Emily’s relationships are put to the test as she moves on to a new phase of her life, but the writing falls flat and the pacing is uneven. The most memorable moment of the episode is when Emily’s father tells her, “I don’t want you to be a spinster, Emily. I want you to have a life,” but even that feels forced and contrived. Overall, this episode fails to live up to the promise of the season, making it a clear contender for the list of worst episodes of “Dickinson”.

Fame is a fickle food

Fame is a fickle food

Release Date: 2021-01-08

In episode 2 of Dickinson season 2, Emily participates in a baking contest in Amherst, which leads to her experiencing a taste of fame and celebrity. However, the episode falls short in its execution, failing to capture the audience’s attention. The characters’ actions seem inconsistent, and the storyline lacks coherence. The dialogue feels forced, and the humor falls flat. Emily’s struggle with fame is an interesting concept, but it fails to be fully explored in this episode. As Emily’s friend Sue puts it, “I don’t think anyone truly knows the cost of fame until they have it,” but unfortunately, the episode fails to deliver a meaningful exploration of this theme.

Forever - is composed of Nows

Forever – is composed of Nows

Release Date: 2021-02-05

In the seventh episode of Dickinson’s second season, Emily falls into a deep depression after thinking she has lost her chance at publication. Her mother takes her to a water cure in hopes of helping her, but things take a dark turn when Emily becomes obsessed with the idea of drowning. The episode feels disjointed and lacks the usual witty banter and humor that make the show enjoyable. The only memorable moment is when Emily’s sister Lavinia tries to convince her to come home and Emily responds with, “I am home, Lavinia. I’m home in the water.” Overall, this episode fails to capture the charm and wit of the show, making it one of the worst episodes of Dickinson.