The Worst Episodes of Sherlock: Avoid These Disappointing Cases

As a devoted fan of Sherlock, I can confidently say that the show is a masterpiece of modern television. With its sharp writing, stunning cinematography, and brilliant performances, it’s no wonder that it has gained a massive following over the years. However, even the most passionate fans can’t deny that the show has had its fair share of missteps. In this listicle, we’ll be taking a closer look at the worst episodes of Sherlock. From convoluted plots to cringe-worthy dialogue, these episodes are a far cry from the show’s usual brilliance. So, buckle up and get ready to cringe as we delve into the darkest corners of 221B Baker Street.
The Six Thatchers

The Six Thatchers

Release Date: 2017-01-01

Sherlock Season 4 – Episode 1 is a jumbled mess that leaves viewers with more questions than answers. The episode starts with a promising premise of someone destroying images of Margaret Thatcher but quickly devolves into a convoluted plot involving a secret sister and a twisted family history. The once brilliant Sherlock Holmes is reduced to a bumbling fool who can’t seem to solve a case without the help of his sister, Eurus. The episode’s attempts at shock value fall flat, with a forced and unnecessary twist that is more confusing than anything else. As the great detective himself would say, “What the hell am I supposed to be doing?” – a sentiment echoed by viewers of this disappointing episode.

The Blind Banker

The Blind Banker

Release Date: 2010-08-01

In the second episode of Sherlock’s first season, the detective duo of Sherlock and Watson find themselves entangled in a web of cryptic messages and a deadly secret society. While the premise seems intriguing, the execution falls short. The episode’s pacing is sluggish, and the plot feels convoluted and contrived. Even Benedict Cumberbatch’s brilliant portrayal of the titular character can’t save this lackluster episode. The climactic scene, where Sherlock and Watson confront the leader of the Black Lotus, feels anti-climactic and underwhelming. Overall, this episode is a forgettable addition to an otherwise fantastic series. As Sherlock himself would say, “The game is on, but the episode is off.”

The Empty Hearse

The Empty Hearse

Release Date: 2014-01-01

As a die-hard fan of Sherlock, it pains me to say that the first episode of Season 3 is a disappointment. The episode opens with the much-awaited return of Sherlock, who faked his death in the previous season. However, instead of delivering the usual thrilling and intelligent plot, the episode revolves around Sherlock’s attempts to make amends with Watson, who is now in a committed relationship. The episode feels like a filler, with the plot only picking up towards the end when a terrorist attack is foiled. The chemistry between the characters feels forced, and the humor falls flat. The only saving grace is the brilliant acting by Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. The episode fails to live up to the expectations set by the previous seasons and leaves the audience underwhelmed. In the words of Sherlock himself, “Disappointing? Being disappointing is what I do.” This episode is a perfect example of that statement. It deserves a spot on the list of the worst episodes of Sherlock.

The Final Problem

The Final Problem

Release Date: 2017-01-15

Sherlock Season 4 – Episode 3 takes the cake for the worst episode of the series. The episode centers around a convoluted plot involving Sherlock’s long-lost sister, Eurus, who has been locked up in a high-security prison for most of her life. The episode tries to cram in too many twists and turns, resulting in a confusing and unsatisfying conclusion. The character of Eurus is poorly developed, and her motivation for causing chaos and destruction is never fully explained. The episode also features cringe-worthy moments, such as Sherlock dressing up as a clown and singing “I’m a Little Teapot” to distract Eurus. Overall, this episode feels like a cheap attempt at shock value, lacking the wit and intelligence that made earlier seasons of Sherlock so compelling. As Sherlock himself would say, “The game is never over, because we change the rules.” Unfortunately, in this episode, the rules were changed for the worse.

The Hounds of Baskerville

The Hounds of Baskerville

Release Date: 2012-01-08

Sherlock Season 2, Episode 2 is a lackluster adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s most famous story, “The Hound of the Baskervilles.” The episode’s attempt at modernizing the tale falls flat, as the plot is riddled with inconsistencies and a lack of suspense. The episode’s portrayal of the legendary hound is particularly disappointing, looking more like a CGI reject from a B-movie than a menacing creature. Even the typically strong performances from Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman can’t save this episode from being a dull and forgettable installment in the series. As Sherlock himself would say, “The game is on,” but unfortunately, this episode fails to deliver.

The Sign of Three

The Sign of Three

Release Date: 2014-01-05

Sherlock Season 3 – Episode 2, titled “The Sign of Three,” is undoubtedly one of the worst episodes of the show. The episode centers around Sherlock’s struggle to deliver a Best Man’s speech at John’s wedding, but it quickly becomes evident that something sinister is afoot. The episode is filled with tedious and overlong scenes of Sherlock trying to come up with the perfect speech, which makes for an incredibly dull viewing experience. The episode’s saving grace is the inclusion of some humorous moments, such as Sherlock’s attempt to dance and his drunken antics. However, these moments are not enough to save the episode from its overall lack of substance. The case that Sherlock is trying to solve is also incredibly convoluted and ultimately unsatisfying. In addition, the episode lacks the tension and excitement that fans have come to expect from the show. The wedding reception setting feels too safe and contained, and the threat of mortal danger never feels truly convincing. Overall, “The Sign of Three” is a forgettable and lackluster episode that falls short of the show’s usual high standards.

The Great Game

The Great Game

Release Date: 2010-08-08

“Sherlock” Season 1 – Episode 3, titled “The Great Game,” is a chaotic mess of a mystery that deserves a spot on the list of the worst episodes of the series. The episode starts off promisingly enough with a blood-soaked car and an empty room with a mysterious clue. However, as the episode progresses, it becomes clear that the showrunners are more interested in packing in as many twists and turns as possible than in crafting a cohesive narrative. The introduction of a deranged bomber, who forces Sherlock to solve a series of cases in a short amount of time, feels contrived and exhausting. The episode also features some cringeworthy moments, such as the infamous “I’m in shock, look, I’ve got a blanket” line. Overall, “The Great Game” is a convoluted mess that tries too hard to be clever and ends up being one of the weakest episodes of the series.

His Last Vow

His Last Vow

Release Date: 2014-01-12

Sherlock Season 3 – Episode 3 is easily one of the worst episodes of the series. The episode revolves around a case of stolen letters that leads Sherlock Holmes to Charles Augustus Magnussen, a notorious blackmailer who knows every personal weakness of every important person in the Western world. The entire episode is slow-paced, dull, and lacks the charm that made the show a fan favorite. Even Benedict Cumberbatch’s brilliant acting skills couldn’t save this episode from being a snooze-fest. The episode’s climax, which sees Sherlock shooting Magnussen, was a terrible attempt at creating a thrilling moment and left many fans disappointed. In short, Sherlock Season 3 – Episode 3 is a forgettable episode that deserves a spot on the list of the worst episodes of Sherlock.

A Study in Pink

A Study in Pink

Release Date: 2010-07-25

A war hero, invalided home from Afghanistan, meets a strange but charismatic genius who is looking for a flatmate; it is London, 2010, and Dr Watson and Sherlock Holmes are meeting for the first time. A string of impossible suicides has Scotland Yard baffled – and only one man can help.

The Lying Detective

The Lying Detective

Release Date: 2017-01-08

Sherlock faces perhaps the most chilling enemy of his long career: the powerful and seemingly unassailable Culverton Smith – a man with a very dark secret indeed.

A Scandal in Belgravia

A Scandal in Belgravia

Release Date: 2012-01-01

Blackmail threatens the monarchy and Sherlock is about to meet the woman who beats him.

The Reichenbach Fall

The Reichenbach Fall

Release Date: 2012-01-15

The return of Moriarty. The crime of the century. Can Sherlock possibly survive?