Adapting novels into movies is always a challenging endeavor. While many novels are critically acclaimed and beloved by readers, their film adaptations sometimes fail to capture the essence of the original. Here are 10 award-winning novels that missed the mark as films.
The Bonfire of the Vanities (1990)
The Bonfire of the Vanities by Tom Wolfe won the National Book Critics Circle Award. Its movie adaptation, however, faced critical panning, mostly because of changes to the storyline and characters. In the film Wall Street hotshot Sherman McCoy’s (Tom Hanks) life spirals out of control after a hit-and-run accident in the Bronx. McCoy finds himself caught in a whirlwind of public outrage, political opportunism, and legal complications. The publicity of the incident exposes the hypocrisies and pretensions of New York City’s elite.
The Golden Compass (2007)
Northern Lights by Philip Pullman was written in 1995. The book won several awards including the Carnegie Medal. The film adaptation, The Golden Compass (2007), disappointed many fans and critics as a fantasy film. This was particularly due to its handling of the novel’s more controversial themes. The movie follows young Lyra (Dakota Blue Richards) sets out on an epic journey to the Arctic to find her friend, Roger (Ben Walker). Roger has been kidnapped by a mysterious organization. Along the way, she encounters various creatures, allies, and enemies, including armored bears and witches.
The Great Gatsby (2013)
There have been multiple adaptations of the classic F. Scott Fitzgerald novel. The 2013 version with Leonardo DiCaprio (Gangs of New York) faced mixed reviews. Some critics believed it failed to capture the nuance of Fitzgerald’s prose. In the film, Nick Carraway (Toby Maguire) recounts his experiences on Long Island’s North Shore during the Roaring Twenties. He became entangled in the lavish and enigmatic world of Jay Gatsby (Leonardo DiCaprio), a millionaire with a mysterious past.
Queen of the Damned (2002)
The original novel, Queen of the Damned (1988) by Anne Rice was the third in her The Vampire Chronicles series. The film was critiqued for its incohesive direction, casting, and lack of depth. Definitely, a fright went wrong. While it had its critics, Queen of the Damned also has its defenders and has garnered a cult following over the years. The film follows the vampire Lestat as he awakens from a long slumber. After becoming a global rock sensation, he draws the attention of a powerful vampire, Akasha (Aaliyah). As Lestat grapples with his newfound fame, he must confront Akasha’s deadly ambitions and protect the world from her malevolent plans.
Love in the Time of Cholera (2007)
Gabriel GarcÃa Márquez’s novel Love in the Time of Cholera is considered a masterpiece. Its 2007 film adaptation received largely negative reviews for not capturing the depth and passion of the original story. Love in the Time of Cholera (2007) is a story of Florentino Ariza (Javier Bardem) and Fermina Daza (Giovanna Mezzogiorno). The pair fell passionately in love during their youth, but Fermina eventually chose to marry a wealthy doctor. Despite this, Florentino remains devoted to her, and over the next fifty years, through affairs and life’s adversities, he waits for the chance to reunite with his one true love.
Dune (1984)
Dune (1984) is a popular science fiction novel by Frank Herbert. While the 2021 adaptation by Denis Villeneuve had a favorable reception, the nostalgic 1980s version did not. Many felt it was polarizing and couldn’t do justice to the complexity of Herbert’s universe. Dune is a story of young Paul Atreides (Kyle MacLauchlan) and his noble family. They move to the desert planet Arrakis, in search of the invaluable spice melange. As treachery and conflict erupt over control of the spice, Paul discovers his destiny as the prophesied leader.
The Scarlet Letter (1995)
Based on the 1850’s novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne, The Scarlet Letter (1995) is a movie about Hester Prynne (Demi Moore), a woman living in 17th-century Puritan Massachusetts. Prynne engages in an adulterous affair with the town’s minister, Arthur Dimmesdale Gary Oldman. When the affair results in a child and she refuses to name her lover, she’s publicly shamed and forced to wear a scarlet “A” as a mark of her sin. The film adaptation took significant liberties with the source material, leading to critical disappointment. The film has aged terribly.
The Shipping News (2001)
Despite Annie Proulx’s novel winning the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Award, the 2001 film adaptation faced mixed to negative reviews. The Shipping News (2001) follows Quoyle (Kevin Spacey), a man who has faced personal tragedy. Along with his daughter and aunt, Quoyle moves back to his ancestral home in Newfoundland. As he takes up a job at the local newspaper and begins to unravel his family’s dark past.
On the Road (2012)
While beautifully shot On the Road (2012) struggled to convey the raw energy and spirit of the book of the same name by Jack Kerouac. In the film, young writer Sal Paradise (Sam Riley) embarks on a series of cross-country journeys in the late 1940s. He brings the free-spirited Dean Moriarty (Garrett Hedlund) and his girlfriend, Marylou (Kristen Stewart). As they traverse America, the trio experiences a whirlwind of encounters, relationships, and personal discoveries.
Endless Love (2014)
Endless Love (1979), Scott Spencer’s novel was a finalist for the National Book Award. Both the 1981 and 2014 film adaptations were critically panned, with many feeling they failed to capture the novel’s intensity. Endless Love (2014) is a film about the privileged Jade Butterfield (Gabriella Wilde) and charismatic David Elliott (Alex Pettyfer). The pair fall deeply in love upon graduating high school. As their intense romance becomes more consuming, they face disapproval and obstacles from Jade’s wealthy family.
The 20 Best Science Fiction Movies of All Time: Enter a World Beyond Your Imagination
Get ready to explore galaxies far, far away and other realms beyond your imagination! Whether you’re a sci-fi nerd or just a major cinephile, we know you’ll love these 20 best science-fiction movies of all time. From space battles to time travel, this list has it all. Grab your popcorn, sit back, and enjoy the greatest sci-fi films in this universe or any other.
The 20 Best Fantasy Movies of All Time: Enter a World Beyond Your Imagination
Get ready to be enchanted as we explore the realm of fantasy films! Immerse yourself in captivating worlds and epic adventures with my handpicked selection of the 20 greatest fantasy movies ever made. From Middle Earth’s mystical landscapes to The Green Mile’s emotional depths, this list promises to transport you to extraordinary realms.
The 20 Best History Movies of All Time: Relive the Past Through the Magic of Film
Calling all history buffs and movie lovers! Prepare for a cinematic time travel experience with our top 20 history movies. From Schindler’s List’s powerful Holocaust narrative to the groundbreaking Hamilton musical, these films will immerse you in the most significant moments of human history. Prepare for a historical adventure like no other- and you won’t even need to leave your couch!
